Option 1 was the big winner! Lobster thought it was one of the least girly ones (although he made sure to note that none of them were as manly as he wanted) and I really liked its antique-y look. So I ordered it online a couple of weeks ago and wasn't expecting it to arrive until after the new year. But I guess Pottery Barn got a new shipment in and they were able to send it early! It's a Christmas MIRACLE! Okay, not really. But I was like a kid at Christmas when it got here!
Anyhoo, I ordered the duvet cover and three euro shams. They are very well made and the color is lovely.
I love, love, LOVE this pillow I found at the Pottery Barn Outlet. I love the burlap look and the message. My room IS my place of retreat. Perfect.
I also love the monogrammed pillow shams Lobster and I got from our wedding registry (Restoration Hardware). Love!
And in a purely random coincidence, I had just recently purchased this sorta matching bed for Killian. Doesn't he look cozy? Awww.
So thanks for all your input, guys! You're the bestest!